Hmmm. Still got 'nuthin…but suddenly realized…I made your banner! I had forgotten that. 
Yes you did! That’s why I’m flyin’ this particular one sweetie 
It’s always been one of my very favorite ones 
You need another hint? Let’s see…speaker was quite a “bully” of a dandy
Prick? Bully?
Atherton, Shindig. Not sure of the scene, but ‘of course’ isn’t a substantial hunk of dialog. I’m going with the ballroom. (Possibly the cut-in scene?)
“It will haunt your dreams and harrow—YES—your very soul!”
Atherton
“Shindig”
Mal asked Ath if he could cut in and dance with Inara.
“You mean like masterbatin’?”
EDIT: Aw Frak, Pike!! Ya beat me.
A Carnie
“The Message”
Simon and Kaylee are walking through the carnival
“You mean like masterbatin’?”
Again with the masterbaitin’…
Yeah. We just had the carpets steamed due to the ‘incident’. I’ll never be able to look at a watermelon the same way again.
…wait, what are we talking about?
Ahhh…and I was just gonna try to stump everyone with
“I’ll be in my bunk.” (there’s two right answers—the line is used twice).
—Yours Truly,
Bunktime
That wasn’t the vodka shooter watermelon, was it?
Wait. Don’t tell me…
this is another good one
ETA: note to self: finish reading thread before replying. Solai and I apparently have the same taste in screencap sources
Jayne, War Stories, when he sees that Inara’s customer is a woman…hehe
Okay since the game is stalled…I’m gonna start it again by answering this one…
Jayne to Book in the galley of Serenity in Objects in Space
Next quote:
Came downstairs for the shiny presents.
Ms. Anders Fan? After you answer the quote in question, you need to leave a quote of your own for the rest of us to guess okay?
That was River in Ariel after Jayne, River and Simon were collared by the purple bellies…
Up Next:
Once was lost, but now I’m found…
_
One of Nandi’s girls singing “Amazing Grace” at Nandi’s funeral, “Heart of Gold”
Here’s an easy (but appropriate) one:
“Is it Christmas?”
Mal in Our Mrs. Reynolds after he comes to from bein’ knocked out by Yosafbridge’s “goodnight kiss”
“Were I unwed I’d take you in a manly fashion”
Wash, Heart of Gold, to Kaylee who’s depressed because everyone’s got somebody but her. Kaylee continues, “Because I’m pretty?” Wash: “Because you’re pretty” (I love Wash)
“A man’s got a choice.”
“I don’t believe he does.”
great line Lady D… The Sheriff and Mal at the end of the Train Job when he is bringing them back the drugs…
Up next:
To wabba hoo?
_
Mal to Saffron, Our Mrs. Reynolds, in response to her ‘cleaving’ line.
“You just lie there and be ironical.”
Mal to Book, Safe, after Book’s been shot and says he may need a preacher
“Everything I have is right here”
Simon to River, Safe.
“What was natty?”
That was said by Hoban Washburne, him desperately trying to catch up on missed conversation the dining room scene in Out of Gas…
Up next:
Thanks. Now I’ll really have the advantage.