To quote Jon Lovitz… “ACTING!”
Why do we beieve that Weaver is a bad ass? Answer: rom her “acting” like a badass. She isn’t physicaly impressive in any way. She is lanky! Her “badass” look comes from her acting, and her face physicaly looking harsh. It makes her look rough.
I will say this about Riply ( well Riply prime in 1,2, and 3) … she isn’t really a “rambo badass”. She just doesn’t see herself as haveing any othre choice. She is scared to death all thru those first three movies.
In Alien… she fights the replicant. He isn’t a combat model. It’s about like if my mom beat up my dad… we wouldn’t call her Rambo! She literaly lives to the end of the movie because of NOTHING that she has actually done. She makes it to the shuttle because the Alien isn’t after her ( he is sleeping in the shuttle). To beat him she does that “bad ass” move of…pushing a button to beat the Alien. Believeable, cool… but nothing that makes her extrodnary.
In Aliens, she is just knowledgable. THat’s her bad ass ness until the very end. She isn’t baddass at all untill the “mother” complex takes her over at the end of Aliens and she sneaks into a hive and shoots and kills , what for the most part are sleeping Aliens and an imobile Queen with her superior ranged weapons. Everything she does is out of either last ditch effort or absolute neccesity. She isnt Laura Croft. She is a middle of the road working woman that rizes above what she is and makes the game winning play. It’s more like Karate Kid than Tomb Raider. Watch the movie… she doesn’t do anything that takes a gymnist or a hero to do… it just took courage! I would think that most of our moms could have pulled that off if the Aliens had us.
in Alien three… she did nothing badass. She knew about the Aliens. That was it… she was knowledgable. I won’t even call that smart… just knowledgable.
A pretty woman could have done all that too.
Riply is 5 inches taller than Fox, but only about 10 pounds heavier ( in Alien and Aliens) …what makes her that much more more badass? Nothing. A woman at THAT low of weight with that Ht statisticaly ( and based on my expierience training my female soldiers) isn’t any stronger or tougher than a woman Fox’s size.In fact her Ht/wt ratio makes her inferior as a soldier.
If you are judegeing Riply’s mind vs Fox’s looks… that’s crazy, cause the writers could just write that she is as smart as Riply and she would be. If you are saying that her being pretty makes her unbievabale as smart… well that’s an issue that I am not touching. I’ll let you and the ladies of the GWC hash that one out and see how well that goes for ya’ll… better you than me on that one.
Plus U have to give Fox this… youth equals better shape, as well as (IMO) being a southern girl, tomboy, swim team member from Tennesee means sh can probably break bad a litte harder than a Prep school gal, daughter of TV executiives from Manhattan. My mony would be on Fox. She brings that “you ain’t my man’s baby mama” to the fight that a privlidged New Yorker can’t hang with!