This kind of conversation is why I love this forum… you sparked a couple thoughts in regards to Kara:
1st: RDM chose to answer the Kara question, “God resurrected her as an instrument/messenger of his will.” Which is apparently ok, cause it’s God, after all. The action is not only divinely sanctioned, it’s a godsdamn miracle – literally. Why is it then ok for the One True God to resurrect one of his own, but immoral for Daniel Graystone to do so? Why isn’t Daniel’s act of resurrection a miracle? And why aren’t we as an audience asked to consider it miraculous? It’s hypocracy. And I’m not buying, “because Daniel’s not God.” I don’t think that’s a good enough answer – omnipotence does not imply omniscience. To me, the OTG is just another jealous deity, like our Old Testament, wanting to keep the power of life and death in his hands only. What God considers good, is not necessary what we consider good. Or, instructed to think is good.
2nd: “At what point is it not you?” I think memory plays a role… I like to think about how sleep and death are similar… how do you tell the difference? How do I know I am the same person when I wake up in the morning? Because I remember what happened to me yesterday? If I didn’t remember, would I still be me? Is that true of people that have amnesia… are they not the same person they were, even though they are in the same body as before?
Agreed… I like the word “backronym” for what that was.
Yes! Bill and Lee’s Sentimental-Drunk-Irish theme! I downed my glass of Bushmills, jumped onto my couch and waved my jacket around my head when I heard that.
and:
The boobs — fantastic. We should definitely have more of those. Just saying.
But seriously, it was startling, and yet not – it’s not difficult to imagine nudity finding a tasteful place in this show (although it never will) – it just reminds me why I like HBO and Showtime, and how frakin awesome it would be if Caprica was on one of those channels, instead of stupid SyFy. It’s feast or famine with those frakers, either incredibly good or incredibly lowbrow.