I was just enjoying some of each and I wondered who would win a deathmatch. I have to go for Reese. Just enough peanut butter to be nice, not offensive. 
M&M’s can wear out their welcome much sooner in my case.
I know what you mean. I love them both, btu Reese’s Pieces are more dangerous (in that I’ll eat a whole bag without noticing, lol!)
Baltars with a candy coated shell, it would sell! Or chocolate Baltars, put in your mouth and bite off the head and find a prize inside! We can make millions, bwa ha ha ha!
peanut butter m&m’s FTW!!!
I loves me some Reese’s Pieces!
Can’t eat peanut butter, so I have to go with M&Ms. Also, they are much more colorful and pretty.
I thot about choosing baltar since I usually mix M&M’s with Reese’s Pieces but this is a Geek Deathmatch and baltar should not be an option.
Anyway, M&M’s have cartoon characters and therefore opposable thumbs which as everyone knows wins on the evolution chart. Then again Reese’s pieces were enjoyed by E.T.
When faced with circumstances such as these, certain measures must be taken. prepares heat lamp Trial by Fire. places M&M’s and Reese’s pieces under lamp waits few minutes muzak playing in background starts to hum tune, it’s Nirvana’s ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit’ realizes Nirvana is muzak ??? prepares to write in ‘When was the first time you felt old’ thread examines M&M’s…melted examines Reese’s pieces…mushy but still in tact
Reese’s have it.
As far as I can tell, Reese’s may provide the ability to fly and ressurect oneself from the dead. Gotta go with them.
It has to be Reece’s Pieces. Besides - everyone knows that the best chocolate around is a Hershey’s Kiss. 
Does this only include regular M&Ms? Cause Peanut M&Ms kick the craaaaaaaaap out of both
I’m going Reese’s, but I have a major weakness for peanut M&Ms. Ooooh, and Mr. Goodbars. Oh, and Pay Day bars…
GAH! WHY IS EVERYTHING GOOD BAD FOR ME AND LOADED WITH CALORIES??? DAMN THIS POLL! DAMN THIS POLL TO HELL!!!
Yea - I stopped at the gas station on the way back to work and picked up a bag of Reese’s. :o
Write in vote: Smarties! Not the crappy sugary type you get in the US, but delicious quality Smarties you get in Canada and Europe! So totally worth importing. Mmmmm …
Went with the Reeses. A bagfull of M&Ms gets sickeningly sweet. A bagful of Reeses Pieces maintains a nice balance, with the peanut butter offsetting the sweet chocolate.
On a side note, the secret of life can be found in a large Dairy Queen Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Blizzard.
I went with Reese’s Pieces because they’re much more scarce than M & M’s, but I crave them more. There must be a hidden strength in them to overpower the easy availability of M & M’s…
When spouse went out to get some other things, he brought me a bag too It’s of course long gone.
Reese’s Pieces! Are you kidding me? M&Ms can’t hold a candle to peanut-buttery goodness.
And don’t get me started on Smarties. UK crowd, can I get a witness!
There’s a British shop in Westford. They have Smarties and all the real Cadbury chocolate you can eat
Whoa. Whoa, Whoa, whoa, they’re not bad. They’re just drawn that way.
Dairy Milk! Flake! Curly Wurly! I need a Cadbury fix, STAT!