I am going comment on Baltar…
The last few episodes have really showcased him, joining the election, winning the election, stranding the fleet on this nasty piece of real estate, surrendering to the Cylon, and finally becoming a Cylon puppet.
At this point in the show - is Baltar evil?
I know we have discussed this nauseam, BUT, let’s compare the re-imagined baltar to the OG 1978 Balter.
Baltar the new never gave up the humans to the Cylon, where the old one was PRIMARILY responsible for the destruction of the colonies.
Baltar stuck it out with the humans, and where it was of benefit or he was directly ordered, he has actually assisted in the survival of the humans, and their prophetic leader. OG Baltar took off with the Cylons and got command of his own base star.
Baltar the new seems genuinely distraught over his inadvertent actions on Caprica that led to the Cylon victory, and if given the chance, it is doubtful he would do it again. OG Baltar actually seemed to want to see the humans killed, which I remember being very confusing to my eight year old mind.
So is Baltar evil? No… He is lazy, cowardly, self-serving, egotistical, short sighted, and very very stupid. But evil… no. I don’t think so… at least not yet. Later in season three, I think he definitely begins to blur the line and allow his self-serving attitude to coerce him in to doing some rather evil deeds, but up till now, he is just a moron.
One thing did confuse me though… Roslin, as president, NEVER ordered Adama to do anything… even when they were butting heads… So what makes Baltar think that he can order Adama around? And why is Adama listening to him… The civilian fleet could have been “ordered” by Baltar to go to the planet, but Galactica should be free to do as they please…