Holy frak, Chuck. Great podcast and all, but I am surprised that you are so relatively easy-going about Anakin’s slaughter of the Sandpeople. As Audra points out, even Anakin makes a distinction between the men and the women and children, and wouldn’t be confessing it to Padme if he didn’t know it was wrong. Why would the disemobied voice of Qui-Gon be calling out, “Ani, no!” while Anakin is laying into the Sandpeople if it wasn’t wrong? It may be a step on the road to total evil, but that doesn’t diminish it being evil in and of itself.
It also strikes me that lumping all the Sandpeople together as “bad people” is no different than the way the humans in early seasons of BSG (and some even now) lump all the Cylons together as “evil.”
I get that this is a fictional universe and all, but it really does surprise me, because Chuck, imo, has taken the lead on really pressing for high moral standards – e.g., the whole “You always have a choice” discussion re: the Pegasus crew during the rewatch last summer. That really impressed me. It really seems like a disconnect that you (along with, apparently, Padme) can find anyway to lessen the enormity of what Anakin does.
Just my two quatloos…