Caprica really got the shaft in terms of schedule, and suffered way worse than LOST. Lost had issues, but the issues were similar to all other shows on network tv - having to run 22-24 episodes for an entire year, and thus repeats were unavoidable. So they tried fixing it with S3 where it had the weirdest schedule ever (6 episodes, then half a year later, the rest), but at least after that season, they finally fixed it for good and did it 24 style - airing in January and letting the show run without repeats for 3 seasons.
Whereas Caprica never had a straight up normal schedule.
- It was a DVD pilot first, right after BSG finished (where I think Caprica also lost viewers there because not everyone was pleased with the finale of BSG, at least not right after it ended.)
- Then instead of airing the season straight after that release, only months later, the actual pilot aired on tv with the supposed full season.
- Then that changed, and it only ran for 9 episodes/half a season, and it got cut off just when things started getting good on the show.
- Then they announced 1.5 to air a year later, which is a LONG hiatus, especially since the show wasn’t even meant to be aired as two separate seasons with a giant hiatus in between to begin with.
- Only to have that date changed again and moved up earlier. Which sounds great, since it’s to a better time slot…
- but at the same time, because they moved up the schedule maybe a month prior to the airing of this season, it got virtually no promotion (or at least, not promoted at the right time slot in the major events like comicon and whatnots). If they wanted to air it earlier, which is great, why not announce it sooner so the show can receive all the promotion it can get?
- And then after 4 episodes of the 1.5 run, they cancel the show.
- Which is a little expected, especially after they moved it up, but then they do us in finally by taking the show out of the schedule completely and not airing the final episodes til god knows when.
- So, at no point in time did Caprica ever had a normal schedule as a show. It changed at every juncture it could change at.
I think other than Firefly (which got royally screwed because the episodes ran completely out of order), I don’t know any other show that had as screwed up (or a as setup to fail) a schedule as Caprica did. I’m less pissed about the cancellation (which was expected given the ratings, and to be absolutely fair, it was an imperfect show with some great stuff but also some not so great stuff, unlike BSG, which started off with a BAM!) than how Scifi treated a show they have no reason to treat so shabbily (in order to make short term money of it, or maybe they were too confident that BSG viewers will watch any BSG related stuff, and thus made decisions - like putting out a pilot DVD first months before the actual season began - they thought wouldn’t affect the show, but did. But Caprica is very different than BSG tonally (plus it took a lot more time for the show to get its bearings - in a way, it is still doing that right now), and it needed the nurture Scifi never gave it).