Ooof. That does indeed depend on your needs.
For example, I’m a Mac guy who decided I needed a PC because of a Mac shortcoming. I wanted to draw directly on my screen and couldn’t justify the expense of a Wacom Cintique tablet, so I picked up a tablet PC instead. It’s fine for running the software I need, but if something ever happens to it system-wise, I’m screwed. If only Apple made a tablet PC… (sigh)
-It used to be that if you worked in the graphic arts (except for 3D graphics), you’d want a Mac. With Opentype, that has changed somewhat, though color management still seems a little wonky on a PC.
-If all you want to do is surf the web, send emails, and organize your finances, you can get by a lot cheaper with a PC.
-If you need to interact with one platform predominantly, work or school for example, there can still be major issues with working cross-platform, and if you already own one platform and are thinking of switching, having to re-buy all your commercial software usually just isn’t worth it.
My usual advise is stick with what you have, because both platforms can do most of what you’ll want.
If you’re starting from scratch, well, I just like the Mac user experience better. The Mac OS just seems to get out of my way.
If I was a programmer/hacker, I’d probably say the opposite though. And with the advent of some really great Open Source programs like OpenOffice, Gimp, Inkscape, Blender 3D, CeltX, Audacity etc, (which can all run on a Mac too BTW) the cost of entry can be so low with a bargain PC that it’s hard to ignore.
Yeah, I know. This hardly clears anything up.
Welcome to the digital age. Sorry.