I totally get what you are saying Leah. My only point was, as I’m sure you are well aware of. So many people think of their dogs as a person & they’re not. They feel you are insulting their pet by saying they are an animal not a person. That doesn’t mean you love them any less or that they are any less a part of your family life. It’s also not an insult to the dog, they are what they are, no matter what we may wish them to be.
I am by no means a dog trainer & would not even think about pretending I was. I just realize that there is animal behavior that is hard wired into them. We as humans don’t understand, fully, a pack animal because it is not in our nature to behave that way.
I also think that one of the biggest issues is, it’s so easy for people to present themselves as some magical dog trainer who’s going to teach you how to be a zen master with your dog. It’s hard to tell the difference between a legit trainer who can give you techniquews that work for you and your dog than from the people just trying to make a buck off of clueless people & helpless animals.
I would not dream of using his aggressive techniques without supervision because I don’t know what the heck I’m doing. Most of his shows are extreme cases that require his type of training, but in the end, he’s the expert, not me.