Inspired by this Russian snackfood commercial:
I just find Luke too whiny.
It’s genic.
My problem is Neo would overwhelm Luke in the Matrix, but not in the real world. So, I’m torn.
first off–regarding the video–anyone who whips out a cow and smacks your head with it is an automatic win. Period.
If we are talking just movies–Neo woukl win - he can do crap to matter etc.
If we go into EU–Luke would win…dude’s a Grand Master…
Since you said “Neo,” it means this match would take place in the Matrix, right?
In Reloaded and Revolutions, he was still Neo outside the Matrix.
At the risk of starting an argument, I interpret the movies as taking place entirely in the Matrix, even the parts that don’t look like it. So I think this poll may be tainted by denominational differences.
I don’t think you can just assume that this battle is going to take place in the virtual reality of the matrix. But it’s true that in a fight within the Matrix, Neo would womp Luke. The problem is that Neo would need to somehow convince, trick, or otherwise use his intelligence to get Luke to electively enter the Matrix (as outside of the Matrix, Neo has no shot of beating Luke at all). So the question really becomes: Do you think that Neo is smart enough to trick Luke into electively entering a fake world wherein he’s completely powerless?
I’m banking on the fact that Neo is dumber than Luke is gullibe.
As for being Neo outside the Matrix: those powers only worked on the machines, whose programming was written in the same language as the matrix. Luke is not a machine with a computer brain. However, the Force works on everything.
^^^^^^^^ What he said. Well put, sir. Welcome to the boards!
Yeah, I’m voting for Luke because of that argument. Thanks. ^^
Can God make a rock so big that He couldn’t lift it?