GWC Podcast #173: Harry Potter, Part I

I am curious as to how people are going to go on the Chuck, “Sort me!” challenge. For reference:

Hufflepuff: Loyal, Dependable, Hardworking
Ravenclaw: Intelligent, Witty, Capable
Slytherin: Clever, Cunning, Determined
Gryffindor: Brave, Chivalrous, Courageous

I can make a fairly solid argument to put Chuck in each of those houses. If I remove all the baggage that comes with our knowledge of Slytherin I would put Chuck somewhere between Slytherin and Hufflepuff with Ravenclaw trailing by a hair.

I agree with Uch in that I’m Slytherin and not Gryffindor, I was tied for both with Ravenclaw a close 3rd and Hufflepuff like not even on the graph XD.

Everyone knows those are the three cool houses anyway. Hufflepuffs are either cool but unimportant or total dbags that makes harry’s life suck. So frak em. Not GWC Hufflepuffs though, actual characters

Well sir, right you are on my account. I’ve taken 6 different sorting tests today and landed square in Gryffindor on each one. So I guess that puts me in Godrics house and the ol’ red and gold. Guess that quick to act thing burns me each time :wink:

still listening to the 'cast but I had to pause and post that Hufflepuff House has its own tv trope.

Where might I get a Slytherin badge? Based on the Clever, Cunning, and Determined I would proudly sort myself in Slytherin.

All this sorting hat stuff got me curious so I Googled ‘Harry Potter Houses’ and took the test. I scored:

Gryffindor- 89
Ravenclaw-91
Hufflepuff- 86
Slytherin- 33

I guess I am Ravenclaw! :slight_smile:

Well on the second test I have taken I have fallen squarely in:

each time. Which is where I thought I would be.

How’s about a key chain? Welcome Brother! :smiley:

IMHO Chuck seems more like the Hufflepuff type than Slytherin (even after unloading its baggage) since his dedication and loyalty to his friends and to GWC comes first to mind when I think of him. But the problem with any test that groups people into only 4 categories is that it’s effectively trying to adequately express people with such intricate and diverse personalities into two bits of information, which is darn well near impossible. That’s I think why many people are difficult to sort and seem to fall on the cusp of being in two houses (like me between Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff).

i listened to the podcast, and the crew were talking about how tightly everything in Harry Potter was planned out. i wonder just how much of it was really planned out. Or did Rowling worked in the same way as RDM? Making things up as she goes because it seemd right at the time and try to piece pieces together later on?

I’m so glad that we’re talking about Harry Potter - it’s held a special place in my heart since I first read it. Many of my close friends had been on my case to read it and I kept turning it down, saying it was “a kid’s book”. How wrong I was!

One reason I think my friends were so insistent is because they had all gone to the Louisiana School for Math, Science and the Arts (aka LSMSA, aka The Institute). Our experience with that school was very similar with what many of the characters in Harry Potter experienced.

Louisiana School is similar to a magnet high school but at a statewide level. Like Hogwarts, it’s a school that most people here have never heard of. Once they determine that you are capable of taking the advanced classes, you receive a letter of invitation (delivered not by owl but by the USPS, but still). The school is based in the north central part of the state, so for the students who lived in the southern portion we would take a bus up to the school and back for holidays (just like the train ride to Hogwarts and back).

Once we got there, we were sorted into different wings of our dormitory (much like different houses). Assignments were much more random than the sorting hat and girls and guys lived in two separate dorms, but there were still some personalities that could be associated with each wing. Living in dorms were a huge adjustment for many of us, especially since there were so many people who were from different ethnicities, social backgrounds, political leanings and focus of studies.

We didn’t have any distinctions between people who were the first members of their family and those who had several brothers and sisters who had attended previously, but we did have names for ourselves (“gifties”) and for what would be considered muggles (“normies”). Normies were considered dim and to be avoided by some and mostly harmless by others.

We didn’t learn magic, but something a lot of us got exposure to were computers. At my high school back home, the closest we got to computer science was typing. Here we had access to a VAX system (I may be dating myself a little bit here) where you could issue commands and things would happen. You could even use it to send messages to each other (again, I’m dating myself - this was before instant messaging) - we used it to talk to the girls after lights out in the dorms.

I’m sorry I’ve rambled so much, but for me this series of books represented an important time in my life - a time of newness and discovery, a time when we were so full of potential.

Hey!! Apparently I’m a Huffenpoof, so I should resent that.

However, I think we’re Huffenstoofs are kinda dim, so I have no clever retort.

I haven’t got to listen to the cast yet as iTunes is being a douche and won’t download it but I have to jump in on the HP discussion.

I have to start off by saying that I give JKR major brownie points for getting kids to read a 7 book long series in the era of video games and internet. For the first five books she had me enthralled with Harry’s world. I read the first 4 books multiple times and blew through OotP in one night the night it came out but when HBP arrived on my doorstep I was so disappointed that I never finished the book nor could I make myself read DH (although I did read the atrocious epilogue when it was leaked online). She had me right up to when we started getting info on Moldyshorts past. I have to admit that my opinion of HBP was marred by the fact I was reading it when I got the call that my grandmother had died. My feelings on Harry Potter are the same as the fans of the original Star Wars trilogy are about the prequels. I was so let down by how things turned out that it pretty much ruined Harry Potter for me.

Oh good - it’s not just me that can’t get the 'cast downloaded. Stupid Itunes!

I haven’t posted much on the boards, but am a long time listener, and just have to jump in on the subject of Harry Potter.

The series is one I love so much and has been an obsession of mine, probably even to a larger degree than BSG :slight_smile: I just wanted to say how awesome it is that my favorite podcast is covering it! Even though you guys may not think you are the experts on the series that some other podcasts are, I think you really touched on some of the reasons the series is so great, the rich world, the characters, the themes of loyalty and friendship, just to name a few.

I do have to say (And I know some people have posted on this already) but Cedric Diggory of Hufflepuff is one of my favorite characters, I cry every time I read the last few chapters of book four :frowning: And I have long strongly identified myself as a Hufflepuff. I’m loyal, hard working (most of the time) and even though we are not always the center of attention, we know we can always count on our friends to support us. Sorry for the rant, but I just had to stand up for my house!

I can’t wait for your next podcast! It’s getting me so excited for the new movie.(OK I would be anyway, but still yeah!)

PS. Ooh, I just thought of something…Go with me for a second…I’ve only thought about this briefly, but I would identify one of my favorite characters from BSG as a Hufflepuff…The Chief…hard working, loyal to his deck crew and commander, doesn’t get the glory of the Viper pilots, but without him, none of them would be able to fly…

PSS Also…so awesome of you guys to include some wizard rock. I hadn’t ever heard of Tonks and the Aurors before, but have been a fan of Harry and the Potters, and even went to one of their shows, which was so cool!

Yeah, Chief is definitely Hufflepuff.

Where would everybody else get sorted?

My guesses:

Baltar, Zarak, The 6’s, Starbuck - Slytherin
Apollo, Geata - Ravenclaw
Adama, Rosylin - Gryfindor
Chief, Helo, Tigh - Hufflepuff

I definetly will go with you on Baltar and Zarak and the 6’s as the ultimate, Slytherins, conniving, cunning, out for themselves. However, though Starbuck does show some Slytherin traits, especially in dealing with her relationships with Lee/Anders, I would also say that she has quite a few Gryffindor qualities, her loyalty, and definitley her recklessness/bravery in battle.

Geata I think, especially for the first part of the series is a Ravenclaw, strictly by the book, which is also why I would maybe not include Apollo here, he does have such a problem with authority, ie his father throughout a lot of the show.

I agree completely with your other Gryffindors and Hufflepuffs.

I would also add the 8s as a group into the Syltherin catagory, just because of their constantly changing loyalties, but would probably exempt Athena from that group

Lisa

Anybody else having problems downloading the cast from itunes?

Here is my take.

Gryffindor
Adama
Apollo
Helo
Six
Starbuck
Kat

Ravenclaw
Roslin
Gaeta
Eight
Leoben
Simon
Doral
Romo
Dualla
Billy

Hufflepuff
Tyrol
Anders
Hot Dog
Cally
Cottle
Tigh

Slytherin
Baltar
Cain
Cavil
Tory
Ellen
D’Anna

P.S. Looks like several people are having problems downloading but I just tried and it worked fine. You can also use the link at the top of this thread or the Blog. iTunes must be full of Nargles. :wink: