I don’t think Baltar was evil…he was a complicated man, but a few simple things gave him pleasure (to quote a tall blonde who will be on “Chuck” next week). I think he was weak. I think he was sensitive. I think he was a coward at times and self-serving most of the time, but, as with all of us, he tried to redeem himself and be a better person (and, as with most of us, failed miserably a lot of the time and fell square on his “SORRY, BARB” the other times). As we saw with his administration and with his cult, sometimes he believed his own BS to both extremes, and with varied outcomes (on New Caprica, his actions and failures caused misery and despair, but they also kept humanity alive long enough for them to escape, and with his cult, whether he was truly a believer or just a megalomaniac, his words and ideas gave people comfort and hope, and in some instances the strength and resolve to carry on through a horrible ordeal…there’s some grace and divinity even in the most base and profane of things). His actions and his flaws led to some horribly evil things, and on some level he is responsible for the holocaust of the 12 Colonies…but he saved Hera on more than one occasion (first, from being aborted, then from New Caprica, then on the CIC). We’re all here because of Baltar. So maybe he’s okay, in the end.
And as for the end of Starbuck (and in turn, the end of the show)…I’m okay with it. The how’s and why’s and what’s involved in trying to define the divine or mystical are really where stories lose their mythology (think about how mediocre an explanation “midichlorians” are for the majesty of the FORCE). I mean we knew that Starbuck was dead and was resurrected…I think the unexplainable mystery is more appealing for this story than the one mired in technological deconstruction that has her be a part-cylon or a clone or whatever. It’s the same argument for Roslin’s visions (notice they start when she starts taking Chamala, and her final “Opera House” vision on Galactica starts when she shoots herself up with her cancer cocktail…was Roslin really in touch with a biblical magic, or was she just hopped up on goofy juice? Was she really the “dying leader” or did she co-opt that role and have the visions and the reality and the scripture morph around her desire to become that? Dunno, but I like to think that she’s connected to a force beyond our comprehension, and if we were to show you a schematic or a blueprint or a formula or a CSI: Miami explanation on exactly how and why and what was going on, it would make it simple and mundane in some ways).
Anyways, I loved the ending. I loved all of the characters coming to their conclusion. I love that even with humans and Cylons living in a stone age existence, that they’ll all still frak and fight and build and destroy, and the cycles of history will continue. Atlantis and Lemuria will rise and then fall, cultures will grow and prosper and some will die off and be lost forever and the Chief will invent haggis and sheep tossing, and then someday the descendents of Galactica will pitch a show in the late 70’s, following the popularity of “Star Wars”, which shows a war against humans and robots, with Vipers and Raiders and Centurions and Colonials, and the legend of Starbuck will be told again. Oh, what beauty. Thanks RDM.