I’m 38 minutes into the 'cast and I’m going in a completely different direction from SeanChuckAudra. I don’t think ByBBQ8 is evil; I think she just has no reason to trust anyone else on the raptor. And I don’t think Gaeta thinks she is scary in a Glenn Close sort of way; I think her he is not sure what to make of her presence. Here’s why:
In the first 'sode, the wanted us to think there was a Single White Female angle to ByBBQ 8, but the scene on New Caprica from 'sode 4 showed something different: genuine tenderness. Gaeta seemed to be writing out the names of people he has not seen in a while. ByBBQ 8 assures him that if they are captive, she will find them because “the Ones keep really good records”. Gaeta is anxious about the list he created – he is acting as a double agent and trusting someone from the “other side” to help him help the “good side”. He probably should be anxious. ByBBQ 8 squeezes his hand, telling him it wil be OK. He does not recoil.
ByBBQ8 also takes a big risk on New Caprica but she trusts Gaeta and, it would seem, her trust is well placed. Their bond, and the anti-Cylon sentiment that remains in the fleet, may inform her decision to share her plan in secret, etc. Gaeta “gets” this and anyway he is good at being observant, keeping his mouth closed, and executing his plans in secret. And he looks anxious because he is facing a huge problem and the solution involves juggling mixed constituencies with differing agendas and prejudices.
I think ByBBQ8’s plan is to narc everyone up with morpha when they are sleeping (not to kill them, but to slow their respirations), mainline into the FTL drive (where we see someone’s palm being cut in 'sode 1), and help get them somewhere they can be rescued. If anyone else dies, it will be an accident resulting from the scheme, but not homicidal mania.
As for the inconvenience of her presence, it could be a lot of things. First, he is not the guy she knew on New Caprica. He’s adjusting to life as an amputee, addicted to morpha, earf is a wasteland, and he was nearly killed by those he saved. What does it mean that this person from his past, who believed in him so earnestly, has come back into his life? There could be an awkward love triangle if Gaeta had something going on with ByBBQ8 on New Caprica with Hoshi on the scene, but that seems a little schmaltzy for BSG.
Anyway, I’ve got to get back to pretending to work.
Anyone with me? (on the theory, not work)