this came to me and for love of spaghetti and meatballs. i just can’t figure a winner. besides all of us; so i put it to the group
Kara Thrace
Aeryn Sun
As long as I’m the mat.
I was thinking towel, but I see the advantages of the mat. 
Sorry Kara, you know I love you. But Aeryn, well… Aeryn is Aeryn. Shes a warrior and a pilot and sometimes even a scientist, and thats a combo I cant turn down. 
Aeryn Sun because she’s sneaky/tricky. Starbuck will punch you in the nose for looking at her the wrong way and sure can fight, but Aeryn is ruthless and smart, she’ll leave you abandoned alone on an ice planet or something.
Everyone knows age and treachery wins out over youth and vigor.
I’m afriad I’m with you guys. Aeryn would stomp Kara in the ground, shoot her and leave the remains on an asteroid - and not think twice about it. And she’d do all of it in black leather pants with a sweet accent.
I’m in.
And Kara would still manage to get off planet and frak her shit up. Then she’d drink Aeryn’s hootch. Gotta go with Starbuck.
The other thing to consider I suppose is whether or not Starbuck can inexplicably resurrect and come back with a new ship every time she dies.
ROFL, I’m sure I don’t KNOW what that means but I’m also sure it’s not what I THINK it means. Though it is an interesting mental picture.
I’ll be in my bunk.
Aeryn sun…but it’d be a good fight.
a good dirty fight…
a good naughty, dirty fight…
…I’ll be in my bunk
Whatever you guys Kara will kick Aeryn Sun’s a…just kidding I have no idea who Aeryn Sun is.
You seem to be confusing the hootch with the kootch…
Whatever you guys Kara will kick Aeryn Sun’s a…just kidding I have no idea who Aeryn Sun is.
Kick-ass Peacekeeper pilot on Farscape. Played by Aussie actress and opera singer Claudia Black, one of my top girl-crushes.
As much as I want to say Aeryn, all it takes is a warm day, and she’s dead.
And considering Starbuck’s ability to, as CardinalFang put it, “inexplicably resurrect and come back with a new ship every time she dies”, Aeryn doesn’t stand a chance against her. 
just saying Aeryn has died and came back herself.
Been meaning to watch that - just haven’t had the time.
Another exciting episode of Adventures in One Letter Off.
Except for MissMuffet and Badger, everyone has voiced for Aeryn yet there are 6 votes for Kara. Alrighty silent folk, let’s her it.
I still want to be the mat.
Aeryn had some help, though. She doesn’t self-resurrect like Starbuck.
We don’t know how Kara resurrected. She could’ve had help. That Viper didn’t grow it’s self.
I love the harbinger of death!
Kara vs Aeryn…
I’ll uh…be in my bunk.
All right, I misspoke. Kara was resurrected by God (or whatever it wants to be called).
Aeryn was resurrected by [spoiler]Zhaan, and it ultimately killed her. :([/spoiler]