11/2008 Winner: "Foundation" by Isaac Asimov

Woohoo! Foundation finally made it! :slight_smile:

As I mentioend elsewhere, this is a book that I was encouraged to read as a child, and I did read it, but I had absolutely no recollection of it. I re-read it (or read, since I donā€™t remember the first time) this summer (along with the folllowing 2 books) and I totally see why I didnā€™t remember it / like it as a kid, but I enjoyed it more now as an adult, even though there are still things that I dislike about it.

I canā€™t wait to see what everyone else has to say about it. :slight_smile:

OK, bought a copy of The Foundation yesterday. Read this a very long time ago and liked it well enough. I wonder how it will strike me now.

Alright, Part 1,
"His name was Gaal ā€¦ "

I like the beginning, when the whole plan is seemingly being laid out. Yeah, right. The whole planā€¦

The sad part is that we could only do the first book. Maximum effect is with the trilogy. For me, the beauty of the story is how things evolve. Transition from scepticism, to acceptance, to acting on their own under the idea of manifest destiny/ā€œchosen oneā€ type belief. What makes the story so interesting is how Asimov takes these very old stories and concepts and throws a curve ball at them to illustrate a point. Historical changes take time. If a plan is really a part of it, then there will a lot of things that might not make perfect sense that need to occur. Second Foundation is by far the best of the Trilogy. How does a plan adapt to the introduction of unforseen chance?

In my senior year of High School, circa 1989. I changed schools, which sucked. Everyone knew each other and I knew no one. I classify this as the worst time of my life.

There was one positive thing that came from it. For some reason, with the transfer of schools I only needed to take 3 classes to graduate. So, I spent my free time in the school library. While searching the shelves I recognized a name, Asimov. As you may know, I am a Star Trek fan. I remembered reading in my stock of Star Trek paraphernalia that an Isaac Asimov was a consultant on Star Trek: The Motion Picture. At this point I had no idea who the man was. As a lad, I read only when assigned to. I spent most of my time watching Star Trek episodes, the Star Wars films, and cartoons (Transformers, Voltron, etc.). A shame I know.

Anyway, I picked up a non-fiction book written by Asimov. As you may know the man puts prolific into another category. The book was ā€˜Exploring the Earth and the Cosmosā€™. It was an account of humanityā€™s discovery of the world around them from prehistoric migrations to space exploration. I loved his conversational writing style. I could grasp and understand every concept so easily. I had to find out more about this man.

As circumstances happen, I was walking through a street fair and there was a book stand with rows and rows of old paperbacks. I spotted Asimov. I picked up the book. The guy behind the stand said, ā€œAh ā€˜Foundationā€™. Thatā€™s his best.ā€ My furrowed brow expressed my ignorance. ā€œYouā€™ve never read this? Youā€™ve got to read this.ā€ Perhaps it was the ā€˜I grok Spockā€™ T-shirt. He grabbed all three novels and said, ā€œ3 bucks. Itā€™ll be the best money you ever spend.ā€ Over the next month I tore through all three and he was correct. Best money I ever spent.

I just stumbled across this article from the Guardian a few years ago, which puts Foundation in a novel light.

I was able to get my hands on an audiobook of this. Unfortunately, the guy reading it was secretly trying to put me to sleep. =/

Very seldom do I find an audiobook narrator who doesnā€™t have that lulling effectā€¦pity they canā€™t all be Jim Dale, though Tim Curry did an entertaining job with the ā€œSeries of Unfortunate Eventsā€ compendium.

BTW, everyone, look for an early-December TalkCast to discuss this (via TalkShoe, like the Snow Crash discussion). Iā€™m looking forward to it!

Maybe Iā€™m spoiled, the woman who did ā€œDarkfeverā€ by Karen Marie Moning was really good. I also love, love LOVED Tim Curry when he did Taltos by Anne Rice. & the woman who does the Stephanie Plumb books is just great!

Iā€™m on The Mayors now. This is pretty awesome, Iā€™m really looking forward to talking about this.

I am looking forward to participating, as well. searches for TalkShoe account

Two quick items of interest:

First, Slashdot links to this piece reporting that New Line is putting together a movie adaption of Foundation. How cool is that?

Second, Iā€™m thinking about, say, next Saturday (Dec. 6th) at 11:00 a.m. ET for the Foundation TalkCast. Sound good?

That is all kinds of coolness. Now they just need to find a director with the passion Jackson had for Tolkienā€™s Rings. I wonder if David Fincher, Christopher Nolan, orā€¦whoaā€¦wait a secā€¦what about Joss Whedon?

Sounds good to me.

December 6th sounds good to me.

How would Foundation work as a movie, though? It seems very disjointed and more focused on themes and ideas than characters, action, or imagery.

What is the name of the TalkShoe cast? Is it the same as Emā€™s but earlier?

My husband has read this series many times, and gave me a bit of an overview. I am really excited to read it, and managed to grab all the books this weekend in my thrift shop/Half Price Books frenzy. Iā€™m going to dig in tomorrow after I am done with my daughtersā€™ lessons.

Finished. Very interesting - I love how this book spans such a large amount of time in such a small package. Itā€™s really allows Asimov to show us things on a macro level without a 2000 page book.

Although I have to admit, I was left feeling it was a bit disjointed, and the ending just felt like the end of Act 1. I guess Iā€™ll have to find the rest of the books and give them a go.

Hereā€™s the TalkShoe link for the TalkCast this Saturday:

http://www.talkshoe.com/tc/31352

Donā€™t forget. The Foundation Trilogy was written as a serial for Playboy and a publisher chose to release the books as a trilogy at a later date. They were not written as three books. The were written as acts (somewhat similar to LOTR).