The 52 “reboot” was sort of a gimmick title (duh!), a more appropriate word would be, “relaunch.” Of the 11 books I follow of the new 52, there has been 1 book which has done an origin story arch, and that’s Superman, and it’s basically the same story we’ve all seen a zillion times. Most of the titles, at least from my reading, are just restarts. Everything has a new story, and all the cross references are in parallel, for instance, Suicide Squad has Harley Quinn’s story line intertwined with The Joker’s from Detective Comics. You may have heard many fans curse DC because they’ve essentially erased all the history and started anew, destroying the decades of dedication to the history these fans have invested. This is not so at all, take for example Batgirl, which follows Barbara Gordon becoming Batgirl once again after a horrific shooting at the hands of the Joker, which took place in Batman: The Killing Joke, from 1988. There have been a few seeds planted about what the whole relaunch is about, but just think of it as a new starting point, rather than a reboot of all the characters.
Having said that, some books are more new reader friendly than others, but I feel all the books are easy enough to just jump into at #1 and go. I have next to no experience with the DCU, so I started with mostly big name heroes. Here’s my reading list.
Action Comics (relaunch)
Batgirl (relaunch)
Batman (relaunch)
Batman, The Dark Knight (relaunch)
Green Arrow (relaunch)
Green Lantern (relaunch)
The Huntress (6 issue mini “relaunch”)
Justice League (relaunch)
Justice League International (New)
Superman (“reboot”)
Teen Titans (“reboot”)
Suicide Squad (relaunch)
All the big name superhero books are basically relaunches. It’s assumed you’ll know enough about the characters to just jump into a new story and go, with little bits given here and there to fill in some back story. Green Lantern is probably the worst offender in this case, however, if you’ve seen the movie you’ll know enough about the Green Lantern’s world and characters to get up to speed. Superman seems to be the only book so far to have a retelling of the origin story, which I find strange because it’s almost completely the same, and his story is the most well known.
All this is just a really long winded way of saying, the best place to start with the new 52, is with whatever characters have you interested. The big name books aren’t true reboots, and having a bit of knowledge of their existing stories is helpful, but you’ll be surprised at how much you already know just through pop culture (do you really need a Batman origin story…again?). The lesser known titles are apparently some of the best, though I can’t vouche for them since I haven’t been reading any. I’ve been hearing great things about Animal Man, and Swamp Thing, for example, and plan to buy at least the first volume in trade so if you’re interested in some of the “non-superhero” books those two are probably the best place to start.
My favorites, of what I’m reading, are Action Comics, Justice League International, Teen Titans, and Suicide Squad. I really enjoy all the other books on my list, but those 4 stand out for me. Action Comics is action packed, and I’m thouroughly surprised that Grant Morrison is writing something that I like since my previous experience with his writing hasn’t agreed with me. Justice League International stood out on my list right from #1, it felt like the best “reboot” at launch time, with a great character introduction and tease to the coming story line. Teen Titans took a couple issues to get rolling, but like JLI, introduces the characters well and has a story line that’s kept me excited. Suicide Squad is just pure action. There’s not much given about each character, but it doesn’t matter because they’ll likely be dead by the end of the issue.