I think Bleach has that sword beat. d:
Definitely not Conan this time…
Ugh! Fantasy draft has left my mind a blank.
That Kill Bill guess sounds pretty good to me. I think it came out in October when it did. That was the height of my Tarantino-mania.
Legend of Neil? Percy Jackson and the Olympians?
Correct! 
Camelot?
First Knight?
Excalibur?
Manchurian Candidate?
Edit: Bah!
Woohoo! It’s the poster that really helped again. I remember that big sword right in the middle of it.
Hm…
Why are you wearing that stupid man suit?
Planet of the Apes?
Men in Black?
Men in Black?
Oh poo, Fastcart beat me to that guess. 
Men in Black II?
Coneheads? (they have to be right eventually)
Easy. Donnie Darko.
Twice that movie has come up. I guess I should watch.
BadgerSpoon’s quick as lightening! 
Go!
ETA:
Oh, whoops, I didn’t know this movie was played already here. Hope it wasn’t the same tagline! But you should watch it anyway - it’s a pretty great movie.
Don’t give away the ending — It’s the only one we have!
Sixth Sense? The Princess Bride?
Sixth Sense?
Clue?
Baltar.
i didn’t realize that it had come up before either.
And yes, excellent movie. 
Nope.
At least three endings, so no.
The Village? Signs? Any M. Night Samalama movie?
Sounds more like a comedy… Hitchhikers Guide?
I hope it’s not one of those Scary Movie parodies.