finally got around to listening to this between welcoming my fireman home and dissecting dr horrible
first point i’d like to address is sexy vader ~ i agree with audra about the tortured teddy bear that women can’t help but want to nurture…also, the description of vader sitting in his oxygen chamber saying “i love puppies” is EXACTLY how i felt about him asking how padme was AFTER the mask was on…should have asked those questions before the mask was in place…
hgh maintenance leia ~ i think what sean meant was she would require a lot of effort to be with
i have to dispute the argument that owen knew what vader was capable of based on his previous contact with him…not sure who said it, but the thing about anakin slaying the sand people, anakin only told padme and the emperor NOT owen a guy he just met…that’s the way the story stands now so owen and beru’s conversation about luke turning out like his father makes no sense anymore…and i think it would have been more horrible of vader ordering their deaths had GL established a stronger relationship earlier on in the trilogy ie owen SHOULDA been that kid kitster someone who knew anakin from childhood and EXPERIENCED his fall also…if anakin was immaculately conceived, then why not have owen be the half brother rather than a step brother he has a casual passing acquaintance with…would have a been a very subtle mythological reference having anakin be the son of a god and owen being the son of his mortal father…THEY WERE NOT HIS FAMILY…he didn’t live with them…he spent an afternoon with them and even that afternoon he went to get his mom and buried her…how much do you think he talked to them?? they were strangers to him so who cares if he burned them??
technically obi wan lied but it wasn’t maliciously the way i keep hearing people make it out…if your best friends son asked you what happened to his father, wouldn’t you want to keep that childs image pure?? IMO it was a lie told for a good reason…you meet your friends son for the first time are you gonna say, " hey yeh you’re dad like betrayed all of us and now is a genocidal dictator!" i totally understood and agreed with obi wans lie…because unlike the generation that got to watch all the movies in one sitting in surround sound on dvd players and hi def tv’s, i am from the generation that had to wait three years in between each movie …that’s a lot of time to think and imagine the answers for yourself!! and the explanation ben gives for telling this lie was perfectly satisfactory to me…and had anakin NOT fallen, of course he would want his son to have his sword…isn’t that what father’s want for their sons?? A LOT of the dialogue in ep four doesn’t make sense anymore because of the first three movies…like i totally imagined ben and owen arguing about the lightsaber but i also imagined that anakin and owen and beru had a more established relationship other than “hey i guess i’m your step brother, your mom never talks about you”…and had owen and anakin had this more of a direct relationship, owen’s anger would be justified and of course he would want to protect luke from anakins fate and want him to have nothing to do with the things that made anakin into vader…but yeh the way the story is now is ben is a big fat liar and manipulating bastard etc etc
i don’t watch the remakes, but i still have to agree with chuck that the effects stand up to the test of time…and YES a good story lasts forever nya nya nya there’s LOTS of dialog from eps 1-3 and parts of rotj that i do that and pretend they don’t happen! or press mute so anakin isn’t so whiny in rots…
sorry audra i’m not as much a fan of padme’s princess leia’s buns…i liked MOST of her hair and clothes but a lot of em were just way to weird looking and unflattering for me!!
i understand threepio not recognizing owen but the way the story stands now, why doesn’t owen recognize threepio???
and the trash serpent spit luke out cause the anaconda don’t want none unless you got buns hon…leia woulda been the next victim if the walls hadn’t kicked in!!