No it’s not suspicious it’s covering your ass because they are professionals & you are not. They like to imply it’s suspicious so you feel compelled to prove your innocence. You are under no obligation to do their job for them.
Snitches never prosper. 
See! The right to remain silence is not legally an admission of guilt, nor can it be used as such. Duh.
Yes please keep reading to me from your rights card
I love how Adama barks “WHAT”
The fact that Adama doesn’t give that Marine shit about his “orders” is a sign that Adama is a good dude
Adama reminds me of Jack in the end scene of a Few Good Men right there…
I will because I know them & will invoke them every damn time
in the “court” of public opinion it’s VERY damning…and a witch hunt is all public opinion…
Nice shot, Helo!
I wonder how getting beat up made Athena feel about being with Helo vs. being with the other Cylons.
Still doesn’t make it right, though. 
“It’s not about right and wrong…it’s about what you can prove” 
Adama’s great here.
“We’re better than that.”
This stand off is AWESOME
Oh, the trouble that could have been prevented if this witch hunt was allowed to progress.
I believe the subtext of that seen is “Frak you Sgt. Hadrian!”
Wooden Ship!
But then we wouldn’t have a story!
Ahhhh the infamous wooden ship!