BSG 1x05 You Can't Go Home Again

I love Starbuck, but I’ve never fully understood why they lost their collective minds that she’s gone

We have left people behind…

Not this time…

Lee and Kara are the OTP of the BSG. The ONLY time I hated Starbuck was well you can probably guess

Cause she’s family? Cause she’s the very best pilot? Wut

well adama just metaphorically punched him in the face

bad images

Both boys yes, but Papadama, no, just no

Because no matter how angry/upset they are about Zak they can’t help but feel like their opprobrium of her actions has led her to this situation, so they feel guilty?

Presentation is just as important as being right. If you can’t present so people listen, you being right is meaningless

yay air but EW gross cylon breathing tube

I was sooooo the same the first time around…I almost wanted to fast forward the whole “stuck on Caprica” thing…it was taking away what I was totally into the first time around…now I look back and go STUPID ME to that…

I’m not watching…I just got into Ohio a half hour ago but did watch this in the morning to try to keep up…I’d watch the second one but I don’t think I can netbook and netflix at once without gumming up the system…

What DP said, and well the fact I am pretty sure Lee has always been in love with her, despite Zach

And Tigh was quite reasonable in how he made the case. Everyone in the CIC knows the Adamas are taking this too far

Utterly true fact. That’s entirely why I identify with Shane. I know I’m/he’s right but I can’t say it in a way that gets people on my side

safety tip number one don’t touch that

<3

I meant this part where Sharon disappeared in Caprica city…trying not to spoil too much since it’s coming up right now

Adama is overrun with guilt because of how PISSED he was at her when she came clean about Zach to him, and hasn’t had time to get past that and say it’s ok I still love you Kara and he won’t forgive himself if she’s dead before he can…

Lee is…well…Lee…and we expect no less…

This I don’t doubt (that they went too far), but knowing that someone you love (whether like a daughter or sister/lover) is in danger/possibly still alive is a whole other topic.

Granted the military training seems like it would override this, but then again, leave no one behind, while it is still a possibility they are alive is another issue as well

Laura Roslin, laying it out.

I LOVE the pissing match here…UNACCEPTABLE.

Ohhhhhh, MY BAD…misunderstood in a hurry to catch up in the thread…sorry…it does make sense once they explain it…but yeah I’d be a lil WTF if I was Helo too (and yes I feel shame each time I rewatch the series at how I disliked this story arc on the first pass)